Imposing an additional tax on so-called “excess profits” sounds very appealing and is an easy way to score political and public relations points, especially when many people are under financial pressure. But the reality is more nuanced. A tax on excess profits opens a Pandora’s box and raises difficult questions about risk, investment, fair competition, and equal treatment of sectors. The issue therefore deserves more nuance than simply the question of whether high profits are fair or not.
Hans van Cleef is Head of Energy Research at EqoLibrium (this column was written in a personal capacity)
In recent months, there has been a lot of talk about imposing an additional tax on exceptionally high profits, also known as windfall profits. That discussion recently flared up again because European refineries, including those in the Netherlands, are benefiting from the sharp rise in energy prices caused by tensions in the Middle East. With oil prices above $100 per barrel and high gas prices, some energy companies are currently making a great deal of money.
To many people, such profits quickly seem unfair. That is why there are frequent calls to impose an additional tax on these companies. Yet the situation is less black-and-white than it seems at first glance. Moreover, such a tax could have consequences that are not always taken into account beforehand.
An article recently appeared in *Het Financieele Dagblad* article about ExxonMobil’s Dutch subsidiary. Although the high profits of oil companies are often highlighted worldwide, the situation locally sometimes turns out to be quite different. For example, a court ruled that ExxonMobil in the Netherlands could not increase pensions in 2024 because the Dutch subsidiary was operating at a loss and an increase would jeopardize the company’s continuity and, consequently, employment. This is consistent with what we have seen more frequently in recent years.
“While some of the energy companies’ trading operations performed well, other divisions actually posted losses”
While some of the energy companies’ trading activities performed well, other divisions actually posted losses. This is because competition in the international energy market is fierce, and profit margins are often slim. At the same time, companies in Europe faced higher taxes, fewer compensation schemes, and additional CO2 taxes. As a result, the profitability of many operations—especially in the Netherlands—came under pressure.
When energy companies suffered losses, there were no calls from politicians or the media to provide them with financial assistance. And that’s understandable. After all, doing business means taking risks and not always turning a profit. But if companies are expected to bear all the risks when things go wrong, while being subject to additional taxes as soon as things go well, it creates a difficult situation.
This is certainly true at a time when the energy transition depends largely on investments by private companies. Many companies want to invest, but have increasingly limited financial capacity to do so. If any windfall profits are later partially skimmed off through an additional tax, investments become less attractive. This could actually slow down the energy transition.
“Once you start taxing unexpectedly high profits, the question arises: where do you draw the line?”
There’s another factor at play. Once you start taxing unexpectedly high profits, the question arises: where do you draw the line? Take the energy sector itself. It’s not just oil and gas companies that benefit from high energy prices. Owners of solar and wind farms also earn more when electricity prices rise. Longer-term contracts in particular—such as weekly, monthly, quarterly, seasonal, and annual contracts—benefit from high gas and coal prices.
But why shouldn’t such a tax apply to other sectors as well? Technology companies have been posting enormous profits for years and are a major reason why stock markets have risen so sharply. While many other sectors are showing only limited growth, major tech companies continue to post record profits. Are those, then, also excess profits?
The same applies to the defense sector. Due to the war in Ukraine and increased defense spending by NATO countries, hundreds of billions of euros are being invested in military equipment. Companies that supply this equipment are operating at full capacity and seeing their profits rise sharply. Should they, too, be subject to additional taxes?
“And what happens if the government itself makes a profit from energy activities?”
The government, too, sometimes benefits from higher prices. For example, when energy becomes more expensive, VAT revenues automatically rise as well. Should that extra revenue then be returned to citizens? And what happens if the government itself makes a profit from energy activities? Do the same rules apply in that case?
If a tax on above-average profits were ever introduced, it would, in principle, have to apply to everyone—including the government itself. But the question is whether the benefits outweigh the drawbacks. Such a system would likely lead primarily to more rules, more paperwork, and more debate over what exactly should be considered “excess profit.” And it is precisely this regulatory burden that has already increased significantly in recent years.