September 21, 2026

Energy Opinion Study: Taxing Windfall Profits Opens a “Pandora’s Box”

Imposing an additional tax on so-called “excess profits” sounds very appealing and is an easy way to score political and public relations points, especially when many people are under financial pressure. But the reality is more nuanced. A tax on excess profits opens a Pandora’s box and raises difficult questions about risk, investment, fair competition, and equal treatment of sectors. The issue therefore deserves more nuance than simply the question of whether high profits are fair or not.

Hans van Cleef is Head of Energy Research at EqoLibrium (this column was written in a personal capacity)