CCS as Part of the Netherlands' Climate Challenge
In line with European climate policy aimed at achieving the goals of the Paris Climate Agreement, the Netherlands, too, faces a significant challenge to reduceCO2 emissions in the coming decades. CCS will play a key role in this effort, particularly for emissions for which alternative sustainability pathways are not available or are limited. As new transport and storage projects are developed, the options available to industrial emitters will increase. In addition to sufficient storage capacity, the costs of capture, transport, and storage are also important factors.
It is against this backdrop that the Abeona project is being developed. Abeona provides for the transport and permanent storage ofCO2 in depleted oil fields beneath the North Sea, making partial use of existing offshore infrastructure. The project combines supply via an existing pipeline from the Amsterdam port area with the option of injecting liquidCO2 directly offshore by ship. This allows Abeona to start operations with a relatively limited pipeline capacity of 1.4 Mtpa and enables the combination of variousCO2 streams.
The most cost-effective route varies by emitter
This study examined, from the perspective of industrial emitters, how the chain costs of transportation and storage via Abeona compare to alternative CCS routes. Various routes were analyzed for emitters in Amsterdam, Rotterdam, and Cluster 6. For each emitter, the study assessed which combination of conditioning, transportation, and storage is technically feasible and what costs are involved. The costs of capture were not taken into account in this part of the analysis.
The analysis shows that the most cost-effective CCS route varies by emitter. Location, emission volume, available infrastructure, and the necessary intermediate steps in the chain determine which route is the most attractive. For a 250 kton emitter in Amsterdam, the pipeline route to Abeona, at EUR 107 per metric ton, is among the most cost-effective routes examined. For an emitter of the same size in Cluster 6, storage by ship in Abeona comes to EUR 117/metric ton, virtually the same as liquid storage abroad. The routes examined via liquid storage in the Netherlands and dense-phase infrastructure prove to be more expensive for these emitters.
In addition to this analysis for a single emitter, the costs associated with multiple emitters jointly using the available infrastructure have been taken into account. To this end, the analysis has been expanded to include Abeona’s expected portfolio, with a combined pipeline and ship volume of 2.5 or 3.1 Mtpa.
Abeona also proves to be competitive at the portfolio level. For the portfolio under review, the average chain costs for storage in Abeona amount to approximately EUR 118 per metric ton. The costs of liquid storage abroad are of the same order of magnitude. Storage via the Dense NL routes under review costs an average of EUR 139 per metric ton. Furthermore, further upscaling of the Abeona pipeline yields economies of scale. If the pipeline capacity is increased from 1.4 to 2 Mtpa, the average supply chain costs for the portfolio will decrease.
Lower chain costs reduce the need for subsidies, making subsidy-free CCS an increasingly viable option
The costs of CCS determine the level of public support required. As long as the chain costs—including capture costs—exceed the market value (ETS price) of avoidedCO2 emissions, an SDE++ subsidy may be needed to bridge the unprofitable gap. For the portfolio examined, the average subsidy intensity after capture is lower with Abeona than with Dense NL. According to the analysis, storage via Abeona or abroad results in an annual subsidy requirement that is at least EUR 52.5 million lower than with Dense NL. Over the time frame covered by the report, this savings could amount to approximately EUR 788 million.
The need for subsidies may decrease further in the future. For processes whereCO2 can be captured relatively inexpensively—such as at a facility in Rotterdam where CO2 is easy to capture—CCS may be feasible without subsidies at an ETS price of EUR 114 per metric ton or higher, provided the most cost-effective route can be utilized. With a higher ETS price and further cost reductions, subsidy-free CCS could become feasible for more processes.
Abeona as a complement to the Dutch CCS landscape
Abeona thus represents a valuable addition to the Dutch CCS landscape. The project adds storage capacity and, by combining pipeline transport with direct delivery by ship, expands the options available toCO2 suppliers. With the completion of Abeona, approximately 2.5 Mtpa in additionalCO2 reductions can be achieved starting in the early 2030s, with the potential to further expand this volume to 5 Mtpa. Further development of cost-effective CCS infrastructure can thus improve the business case for industrial emitters while simultaneously reducing the need for public support.